Google Ads vs. Facebook Ads for Contractors: Which Should You Run First?

Google Ads vs. Facebook Ads: what's the real difference?

Most comparisons treat these two like rival brands of the same tool. They're not. They do two different jobs, and once you see that, the "which one" question gets a lot easier.

Google Ads catches demand that already exists. Someone's water heater just died. They type "water heater replacement near me" into Google, and your ad shows up at the top. You didn't create that need — you just showed up at the moment it turned into a search. That's why search clicks cost more: the person on the other end is ready to hire today.

Facebook and Instagram ads create demand that doesn't exist yet. Nobody is searching for a new patio cover while they scroll at 9pm. But show them a finished one in a yard that looks like theirs, and some of them start thinking about it. Meta ads reach people before they're shopping, which is why the attention is cheaper — and why those leads usually take more follow-up to close.

Neither one is "better." One is a net at the bottom of the funnel. The other fills the funnel. The question is which one your business needs first.

Which should a contractor run first?

For most contractors, Google search comes first. It's the shortest line between an ad dollar and a booked job, it's easier to judge quickly, and it pays for itself fastest when the budget is tight. Then add Facebook and Instagram once search is profitable and you want more volume than search alone can deliver.

But "most" isn't "all." The right answer depends on two things: how urgent your work is, and how visual it is.

Run Google first if your customers call with a problem

If your phone rings because something broke, leaked, stopped working or got infested, you're in a search business. Homeowners don't browse Instagram for an emergency plumber — they Google one and call whoever looks legit and answers. That covers:

• HVAC repair and replacement
• Plumbing, drain and water heater work
• Electrical repairs and service calls
• Roof leaks and storm damage
• Pest control
• Garage door and appliance repair

Consider Meta first if your work sells with a picture

If your jobs are planned weeks or months ahead and the finished result looks great in a photo, Facebook and Instagram can pull their weight from day one. Fewer people search for these services, and the ones who do are shopping every competitor. Meta lets you get in front of them earlier. That covers:

• Pools, patios, pergolas and outdoor living
• Artificial turf, landscaping and hardscape
• Kitchen and bath remodels
• Concrete, pavers and decorative coatings
• Solar, windows and exterior upgrades

A quick way to decide

What about budget? Can you afford both?

If you only have a small ad budget, pick one channel and do it properly. Splitting a small budget across two platforms usually means neither gets enough data to learn, and you end up deciding "ads don't work" based on two half-built campaigns.

Here's a simple illustration (round numbers for the example, not a quote or a benchmark): a contractor with $1,500 a month to spend puts all of it into Google search for the first 60–90 days. Once those campaigns are producing booked jobs at a cost they're happy with, they add another $500–$1,000 a month on Meta — part of it retargeting people who already visited the site, part of it showing finished jobs to new homeowners nearby.

If you're not sure what your total should be, start with how much a contractor should spend on marketing, which walks through setting a budget backward from the number of jobs you want.

Are Facebook ads leads worse than Google leads?

They're different, not worse. A Google lead typed in a search because they need help. A Facebook lead tapped a form because your ad looked interesting. That second person was often doing something else two minutes ago, so they're easier to lose.

That's where a lot of contractors get burned. They run Meta ads, get a pile of form fills, call them back the next afternoon, and find half of them don't remember filling anything out. Then they conclude Facebook leads are junk. Usually the leads were fine — the follow-up was too slow.

Meta leads close when you:

• Respond within minutes, not hours — a text back right away beats a call tomorrow
• Follow up more than once, over several days, by text and call
• Use a form with one or two qualifying questions so you're not chasing people outside your area or price range
• Keep retargeting people who didn't book yet with reviews and before-and-after photos

Google leads need fast response too. Someone searching for an emergency repair is calling the next contractor if you don't pick up. Either way, the speed and follow-up after the click matter as much as the ad.

How Google Ads and Facebook Ads work together

The best setups don't pick one forever. They use each platform for the job it's good at:

1. Meta introduces you. A homeowner sees your finished work a few times while scrolling. They don't call yet, but they remember your name.
2. Google catches them when they're ready. Weeks later they search for the service. Your ad and your Google Business Profile show up, and now you're the familiar name instead of a stranger.
3. Retargeting closes the gap. Someone clicked your Google ad but didn't call. Meta shows them your reviews and recent jobs until they're ready.

That loop is why contractors who run both well often find each channel performs better than it did alone. It's also why you judge the whole system by cost per booked job, not by comparing each platform's cost per lead in isolation.

Common mistakes on each platform

Google Ads mistakes

• Broad keywords with no negatives. Without excluding terms like "jobs," "salary," "DIY" and "how to," you pay for clicks from people who will never hire you.
• Targeting too wide an area. Showing ads in towns your crews won't drive to wastes budget fast.
• Sending clicks to your homepage. A page built for the specific service, with a phone number at the top, converts better than a generic homepage.
• No call tracking. If you can't tell which searches produced booked jobs, you can't cut the ones that don't.

Facebook and Instagram ads mistakes

• Stock photos. Real photos and phone video from your own jobs almost always beat polished stock images.
• No offer. "We do roofing" gives nobody a reason to act. A free inspection, a seasonal tune-up or a clear next step does.
• Slow follow-up. Covered above, and it's the biggest one.
• Turning campaigns off every few days. Meta needs steady data to find your buyers. Constant stopping and restarting keeps it guessing.

The part that matters more than the platform

Whichever you run first, the ad only buys the chance at a job. What turns it into one is what happens next: the call gets answered, the missed call gets a text within seconds, the lead gets follow-up for days instead of one attempt, and the happy customer gets asked for a review. Skip those steps and both platforms will look expensive. Get them right and both get cheaper, because more of every dollar ends up as a booked job.

That's the system we build for contractors: Google Ads management and Facebook and Instagram ads, plus an AI receptionist that answers 24/7, missed-call text-back, CRM follow-up and review requests — all for a flat $750 a month, with ad spend paid directly to Google and Meta. If you're a Las Vegas contractor, see how it works on our done-for-you marketing page or check pricing.

Frequently asked questions